Customer Testimonials

  • 5 stars
    196
  • 4 stars
    0
  • 3 stars
    0
  • 2 stars
    0
  • 1 stars
    0

Jay S. Quigley, P.A.
(196 ratings)
5 out of 5 based on 196 ratings.
196 user reviews.
testimonial quote

Jay is the consummate professional who always goes the extra mile to satisfy his clients. He knows the area and pays close attention to detail. There is no better person for the job!

Kris
testimonial quote

Jay takes his clients through the real estate process, and does so with education, care, diligence, and fairness. I?ve seen first hand the great results he gets for his clients.

John D
testimonial quote

Jay is the best. I've sold many properties along the way and Jay is by far the best agent I have ever dealt with. Attention to detail, excellent service, great advice and a great personality. Very happy.

Tod Sizemore
testimonial quote

Jay Quigley was amazing. True professional and good friend now. Great experience.

Jennifer Esz
testimonial quote

Jay Quigley went above and beyond representing us during our frantic search not only for a rental but for our forever home. I feel like we not only found a realtor for all our needs but we also established a friendship that will last a lifetime. 5 stars or a 10 rating is not enough to put into words what Jay has done for us. Thank you so much Jay, you were Heaven sent! You rock!!!

David Borders
testimonial quote

Jay is the ultimate professional! He is knowledgeable, sincere, and helpful. As a realtor, he provides advice and advisement that is in the best interest of my family and my financial situation. Jay is also a wonderful person who regularly serves his church, profession, and community!

Ian Graulich
testimonial quote

Jay is truly an expert in his field. He knows Tampa like the back of his hand and is a great resource to help with the most important purchases in your life. Very down to Earth and an all around great guy that you want in your corner as an advocate. 5/5 would recommend to everyone I know!

Michael Hardman
testimonial quote

"Jay was great. Very knowledgeable and fun. "

Tealia DeBerry
testimonial quote

"Great job! Looks like I finally found a good RE agent."

Michael Moore
testimonial quote

Jay has been such a blessing to our family! He brought to the table intelligence, kindness, and strategy. He listened to our needs and desires and gave us honest guidance that fit our best interest. He is very knowledgeable, honest, and a magnificent communicator. Do yourself and family a favor and invest in the gold standard asset that is Jay Quigley. I will definitely be using him again!

Leatha Luttrell
testimonial quote

A big thank you to Jay Quigley of Florida Executive Realty for working with us to find a home in Florida! Jay is personally invested in helping his clients to make sound financial decisions, as well as finding a home that fits their needs. He has been a valuable resource and guide to us. We cannot thank him enough for his professional guidance and friendship throughout this process. If you are looking for a knowledgeable agent in the Tampa area, we highly recommend Jay Quigley! He's the best!

Melissa Suhs
testimonial quote

Jay is extremely professional, organized, efficient all while being very personable. In addition, his communication skills are exemplary. It was a pleasure to meet and work with Jay as he helped keep my stress level of purchasing a new home at bay. Out of ten stars, I would rate Jay with 12 stars! A real pleasure! Thank you!! Dawn

Bob Clarkson
testimonial quote

I love everything that Florida Executive Realty stands for. Our service through them with Jay Quigley was smooth and such a relief as first time homebuyers!

Hannah Ray
testimonial quote

Jay was a true professional throughout the process of selling our home. He helped us find reliable, high quality suppliers to do upgrades and repairs. Since we lived in NJ, he handled all of the day to day for us and we trusted him implicitly. I would hire Jay is a heartbeat. Excellent experience!

Julie Pajic
testimonial quote

Jay could not be more of a blessing to me and my family! Just when we were about to give up on our house hunt, we met Jay and our spirits were lifted. His knowledge and patience are out of this world! We are set to close on our very first home for our family, and we could not be more excited! There is no way we could have gotten this far without Jay and the amazing team of resources he has in his back pocket! Not to mention.... he answers his phone! ?? Thank you, Jay, for everything you?ve done for our family!

Hannah R
testimonial quote

"Jay was very professional and answered all my questions! He really helped me get the home of my dreams. My family and I are very grateful!"

Jason R
testimonial quote

I could not praise Jay enough and his efforts to help us relocate from Ohio to an area we have never been to. We came to Florida for our employment and gained an incredible asset in real estate and friend. Thank you isn?t enough for the help Jay have us. We will definitely use Jay again for our permanent move.

Jennifer and David
testimonial quote

"What a great experience! Jay helped us find the perfect home for us!"

Lucie B.
testimonial quote

I would like to start by saying, Jay Quigley was great to work with! He is an honest straight forward professional who always puts his clients best interest first. Fortunately, we were able to find a home quickly with some research of our own and Jay's guidance. However, Jay showed just how dedicated he is to his clients the day of our inspection when the homeowner had not cleared the access to the attic. Determined to have a thorough inspection, Jay rolled up his sleeves and moved everything that was in the way to allow access to the attic. We are so thankful for this because our inspection revealed a substantial roof leak in this area. Jay ended up enlisted his own contractor to look at the damage, since the homeowner was unable to get someone out to estimate the work that was needed. Jay was also able to negotiate a credit for the repairs but ultimately the appraiser required the work to be completed before closing. Jay had warned us of this possibility. This and the homeowner not being ready to move out pushed our closing back a week but Jay, always with a positive out look, helped me keep it together. In the end, Jay would be unable to attend the final walkthrough and closing due to a week long class that he had already committed to. He placed us in good hands however. Dave Lechuga stood in for Jay and really did a great job. Thank you to both of these wonderful gentlemen and Florida Executive Realty for making this home buying experience a great one.

Jason Pigford
testimonial quote

Jay was amazing at showing us the property and answering all the questions we had and quickly respond to any he didn?t have the answers to right away and got everything worked out simply and quickly!

Blaze A. Drinkwine
testimonial quote

"I highly recommend Jay. ?He is a wealth of knowledge for his clients and goes the extra mile to make sure they are properly informed."

T. Pettygrue
testimonial quote

I have known Jay Quigley for over 20 years in the paralegal setting. Just recently I had the need for some advice regarding selling my home. I am also a realtor and real estate paralegal for 20+ years. It became very clear after a 30-minute conversation that I should entrust Jay with my sale. That sale turned into Jay also selling my mother's home and then my mother and I purchasing a home together. All-in-all two sales and a purchase in less than two -month's time. Everything went so smoothly and closed on time. Any issues we had, Jay had everything under control in a timely and satisfactory manner almost immediately. Jay is not only a friend, but a professional colleague that I would recommend hands down to anyone! I am beyond thrilled with his knowledge, dedication, and pure devotion to his clients.

Teresa Hunter
testimonial quote

My husband and I bought a new construction home with the help of your agent, Jay Quigley. He was very knowlegeable and was always available to us throughout the process. From the very beginning, Jay worked on our behalf, assisted us with reviewing the builder?s contract, and even negotiated a significant builder credit that went towards our closing costs. In addition, Jay recommended that we obtain our own third party home inspection company to inspect the home at various parts of the construction and I?m glad we did. Our inspector was able to identify various issues and have them corrected by the builder before moving onto the next phase of construction. We are so happy with the service Jay provided that we will definitely refer him to our family and friends.

Ada Valiente
testimonial quote

A well deserved acknowledgement to Jay Quigley. My elderly parents had to put their house up for sale. Jay walked into a tough situation. The house needed help....big time. Jay coordinated repairs, suggested and implemented upgrades....etc. He did this in just over a month. He told me....Rick I'll have it on the market by the end of January. I smiled, said great but thought....yeah right. He did. Oh by the way, folks.....the house sold the same day he planted the for sale sign in the front yard....If you want a diligent, tireless, savvy agent in your corner or families corner....please seriously consider Mr. Jay Quigley....Florida Executive Realty. He's not a miracle worker.....but he is darn good and honest....thanks so very much Jay.

Rick Matthews
testimonial quote

Mr. Jay is a pleasure to work with. He took the time to find just the right home for my wife and I, we will deffinitely be using him again very soon. He has the pacience and professionalism which makes him the best at what he does.

Raymond Portalatin
testimonial quote

I work with a lot of different real estate professionals. Jay is one of the best... not only in his profession, but at life in general. Jay?s clients are blessed to have found him!!

Ashley W
testimonial quote

Jay Quigley walked me through the home buying process with patience, kindness and humor. He gave me the information I needed to make the best possible choices. Most importantly, he gave me honesty and earned my trust. We reviewed homes and situations pragmatically, and I could always rely on him to be my more experienced pair of eyes. He also made the experience as stress free as possible, acting as my advocate to make sure everything was on the up and up and running smoothly. He had my back and made the demands he knew I wouldn't. I sincerely appreciate his service, and am so glad I made a new friend.

Stacey M.
testimonial quote

Jay was really professional and on time. He made the process very easy and smooth. He was with me every step of the way and gave me good advice. I appreciate him very much and I have to say that he is awesome and I'd definitely recommend him to everyone I know.

Petter Younan
testimonial quote

Working with Jay in finding a new home for me and my husband turned what could have been a very stressful situation into a most rewarding and enjoyable experience! Besides being incredibly personable, Jay is extremely professional and knowledgeable in his field. He went over and above in emailing us listings, setting up appointments and spending as much time as we needed until we found the home we wanted. We could not have asked for more and highly recommend Jay to anyone that is in need of a realtor.

Fanny Lyons
testimonial quote

This past summer my family and I found ourselves needing to find a new home within two weeks.our landlord had decided to put the unit we've lived in for the past three and half years of on the market. We were given two weeks to vacate. A mutual friend referred Jay Quigley to us. He was cordial, professional but most importantly, listened to our needs were. The very next day he had some units lined up for us to see. That same day we found the home we needed and were able to move in within the two week time frame. To say we we were happy or pleased with Mr. Quigleys efforts would be an understatement. We highly recommend him and when the time is right, we plan on purchasing a home with Mr. Quigley's assistance.

Will Perez
testimonial quote

Working with Jay was a great experience! Trying to find a rental in FL while still living in PA was definitely a challenge and Jay made the process so much easier. Jay was willing to provide a video tour of our properties of interest and made us feel comfortable renting something without being able to see it in person. I would not hesitate to contact him again for any of our rental/home buying needs.

Maddy L
testimonial quote

Jay was super helpful us in finding a rental when we moved to Tampa this summer. We met him because we were interested in a rental property he had listed. When that did not work out, and we had to leave town having only been in Tampa for the weekend to find a place, he helped us narrow down the search and sent us videos of three different houses that he created so we could decide which one we wanted. He was also the liaison for us with the property management company. Jay went above and beyond our expectations.

Usha M
testimonial quote

We went with Jay for both the sale of our old home and the purchase of the new one. We asked a million questions and he was always communicative and responsive. He really did an all around fantastic job. We had a few hiccups along the way from the other side, and Jay smoothed them right out without us feeling any impact. We followed his advice from start to finish, and as a result our townhome sold in just 6 days, for above asking price. We highly recommend him.

Jen
testimonial quote

Jay Quigley is that rare realtor who truly listens to his clients and will go the extra mile to insure that they are in the home they truly want. One can call or text him virtually any time of the day.

Laura A
testimonial quote

Jay was referred to me by a friend after I had spent months looking for a rental property with no tangible results. Less than two weeks later we've signed a lease to our new home and will be moving into it the 1st of May. I HIGHLY recommend his services.

B-Chan Zabytko
testimonial quote

Jay got thrown into a non-optimal position helping us find a property on a condensed time line. I greatly appreciated his kindness and professionalism through it. Its rare to find a competent and hard working realtor with constant and stable morality. Situation encompassed more than one realtor assisting us simultaneously, which often results in negativity or persuasive technique used by realtors to guard their self interests. From the beginning there wasn't a critical or divisive word. Jay is an active conversationist who focuses on listening. He didn't try to control the conversation, but instead leveraged it to learn our situation, needs and desires. He learned more about us in a day than many realtors learn through an entire working relationship. We greatly appreciate Jay getting us where we needed to be. Quick, professional and ethical. Highly commendable!

Brian G
testimonial quote

Jay was referred to my husband and me by a friend because we were having a tremendous amount of trouble finding a rental property on our own. She knew that despite the fact he might not make a penny of money, he would still want to be of assistance to us! He has gone FAR above and beyond what we have asked. He was prompt beyond what I expected in his communications with us and diligent in the search for properties we might be interested in! He began showing us properties right away and during the process was always a joy to talk to and often made me laugh. He was consistently upbeat, positive and helpful! We couldn?t have asked for a better experience with ANY other realtor. In the past, I have been turned off by folks in the real estate business. I worked in the industry myself and typically they seemed more interested in making sales and not so much beyond that. Jay is much more interested in a relationship and being helpful in the search and if he makes a sale in the process that?s great. There is no one I have yet to meet that I would want to recommend more to someone! He will ease your stress and find you ?just? what you are looking for. You will NOT be disappointed with him at your side! We are so thankful we were led to him and look forward to working with him in the future and are blessed to call him a friend as well now.

Tracy H
testimonial quote

Jay helped our family find a new home quickly. He was professional friendly and knowledgeable through out the process. I highly recommend his services. Best Realtor in the biz.

Shannon B
testimonial quote

I recently had the opportunity to work with Jay and it was awesome!Throughout the process Jay always placed our clients first above everything else. He was very easy to communicate with, is very professional and I would be delighted to work with him again.

Edgar D
testimonial quote

Jay did a nice job of helping us list this vacant property which was in our family for a very long time. Jay stayed on top of the details and kept us apprised at every step along the way. In short, his professionalism and attention to detail made this a very pleasant transaction. We would highly? recommend Jay!

Jose B
testimonial quote

Jay was very diligent and focused during the sales process. He worked extensively marketing and showing the home. Would recommend Jay in a heart beat to anyone who needs a great Realtor.

Joe C
testimonial quote

Jay went above and beyond to help us find our home. He was with us every step of way, from just showing us houses to giving us guidance with financing our loan. He takes a personal interest and is 100% committed to helping you find your future home. I could have not asked for a better experience.

acetaymad
testimonial quote

Jay patiently worked with us as we sifted through many homes looking for the right fit. He was always professional, helpful and fun. Jay went above and beyond the call of duty during the final negotiations to help us close the deal.

jime64
testimonial quote

Jay was a huge help buying our home. As a first time homeowner, my husband and i weren't knowledgeable about most aspects of the home buying process. Jay explained every process along the way. He was quick to look for homes and show us any we were interested in. He also made the process a lot of? fun. We appreciated his help and would definitely refer our friends to him.

ildetorressierra
testimonial quote

Jay Quigley was very detailed, personable, and responsive. My wife and I are first time home buyers and Jay did a great job informing us throughout the process. He was an excellent negotiator and his experience as a paralegal was especially helpful when it came to ensuring the quality of our? contracts. I would recommend him to anyone who asks. We knew we'd be getting a house during this process, but we came out with a great friend as well!

zuser20140607180016596
testimonial quote

My family was moving from the Midwest to the Tampa area at the end of 2015. I had already relocated to the area and rented an apartment until we could find a home. Jay understood the urgency we had to get our family into one home and really put in the extra work to help us accomplish this in a? very timely manner. With me not really knowing anyone in the area, Jay insisted we go visit some areas around town on off days so I could get familiar with the city, and look at the neighborhood options. This was a huge part of our home buying stress, not knowing a new city, and he took time away from his family on the weekends to get us comfortable with our situation. Around the holidays, like any family maintaining two households money was tight, and I couldn?t afford to go home for Thanksgiving. Jay and his family insisted I come to their home. I was honestly dreading the whole home buying process, but Jay went above and beyond to make it as painless and effortless for me and my wife. I was and still am very impressed with the level care he put into our home buying process. We still keep in touch to this day.

theburlap1
Disclaimer: All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. Neither listing broker(s) or information provider(s) shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless. Listing(s) information is provided for consumers personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information on this site was last updated 06/01/2026. The listing information on this page last changed on 06/01/2026. The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of Delta Media Group MLS (last updated Mon 06/01/2026 8:29:09 PM EST) or Stellar MLS (last updated Mon 06/01/2026 8:16:00 PM EST). Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Florida Executive Realty may be marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about those properties will include the name of the listing broker(s) when required by the MLS. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy / DMCA Notice / ADA Accessibility

Login to My Homefinder

Pixel